National Referenda

posted by TromboneErik on December 12, 2024 - 7:32pm
Vote on this topicThumbs upThumbs down
Current Score: 0

Voters in many states, such as California and my own state of Washington have the option to vote on state-wide initiatives.

Proponents say that voter initiatives represent true "grass-roots democracy" and enable sound legislation to get passed that otherwise would NOT have been by the state legislature (e.g. Public Campaign Financing in Maine and Arizona).

Opponents say that Big Money interests have even more influence over initiatives than they do over politicians. They can influence the draft of proposals so they are confusing or just plain bad - then take out TV ads that confuse and misinform the public. Other critics say that the typical voter will not truly study the issues and vote correctly. Why have paid representatives if we all vote for the prettiest blonde a la American Idol?!

What do you think?

Would National Referenda be desirable?

What U.S. Constitutional issues exist that might block its implementation?

What national issues would benefit from National Referenda? Which ones should be avoided?

Is this a Unity'08 issue?

Comments     Date sort icon
Mark Greene on December 14, 2024 - 9:19am

I remain very skeptical of referenda for the reasons you state above. Having been involved intensively in grassroots political activity for some time now, I realize how easy it is for special interest money to dictate the course of this type of action. I would expect big money to get very much behind this sort of a movement should we ever get effective finance reform in place. The folks with the money will not go skulking off with their tails between their legs, and the referendum movement is a very viable vehicle through which they will seek to continue their dominance of local, state and national policy.

Mark Greene
Texas Democrat in the Middle

Ayesha Haqqiqa on December 13, 2024 - 8:16pm

would require a constitutional amendment; as I understand it, only Congress can pass laws. I have lived for a number of years in Arkansas, a state that allows referenda, and I have seen the chicanery that can occur in the wording of proposals. But I still think they are a good idea, if the public is educated as to the facts about a proposal. Any Constitutional amendment would have to spell out exactly how a referendum could be allowed to come before the public, including something about the wording being clear.

MFV on December 13, 2024 - 6:13pm

Just a short time ago I would be for the referendum at the national level, but now am opposed. I think we need for our leaders to do their job. I am still very much for it at the state level. I believe at the national level it would be too divisive.

A Sooner Independent

Container Bottom